One would be hard pressed to launch an argument against Intelligent Design without including the bankrupt worldview of Darwinian evolution. Essentially, we can determine that God made everything, or more or less, the natural world is self-made. Further, to assert that anything or anyone other than God is responsible for the creation of the universe is calling God a liar. The Bible tells us plainly in John 1:3 and Colossians 1:16 that God (or more specifically in John 1:3 that Jesus Christ) is the Creator, not random happenstance.
Another interesting point regarding evolution is that it is commonly accepted that some mutations actually will improve a species. Who decides if these changes over time actually make a particular species better or worse? How are these value judgments decided? Imagine if some monkeys sprouted wings. Are these wings a product of evolution, which implies that these changes are favorable to the species? Who gets to determine that winged monkeys are superior to regular wingless monkeys? What shapes their worldview?
The argument for Intelligent Design also falls short. Evolutionists can cite “imperfections” in genetic make ups, and an argument for Intelligent Design can challenge these “imperfections” by stating that these traits are in fact perfect for the species in question. However, there are imperfections in genetic makeup, and without citing God as the Designer and The Fall in Genesis 3, one is hard pressed to fully explain these “mistakes.” The Bible explains that sin cursed creation, and that curse is the cause of these defects.
It seems that science cannot wait for evolution to improve humanity. Instead of waiting on contrived science to bring about a new age for mankind, scientists are meddling with human genetics and making value judgments as to what traits are more desirable than others. Everyone can agree that disease certainly is not desirable and the use of this knowledge could be a boon for humanity. But human enhancement is not about medicine. Steward states, “Human enhancement refers to the use of technology designed and implemented not for medical reasons but for enhancing the human body.” Science fiction has covered this subject for years, and now we are on the cusp of engineering superior intelligence, enhanced senses, and in general, making people more human than human. Again, how are we to determine what traits are more desirable? From a biblical perspective, mankind had an opportunity for perfection and we blew it. From a worldly perspective, anything is on the table. Maybe people will be engineered with bioluminescence. Who doesn’t want to glow in the dark?
In all seriousness, when genetic engineering wanders beyond curing people of disease and packages human enhancement as a commodity like plastic surgery, it is perverted as we are usurping abilities that should only belong to God and the day will come when mankind realizes the true fruits of genetic tampering.